Skip to main content

lemmy - Link to source

On Rust, Linux, developers, maintainers
There's been a couple of mentions of Rust4Linux in the past week or two, one from Linus on the speed of engagement and one about Wedson departing the project due to non-technical concerns. This got me thinking about project phases and developer types.

On Rust, Linux, developers, maintainers

There's been a couple of mentions of Rust4Linux in the past week or two, one from Linus on the speed of engagement and one about Wedson...
Dave Airlie (Blogger)

reshared this

in reply to Jure Repinc

solrize
lemmy - Link to source
solrize
• •

Talks about different developer styles, slightly interesting and not too long winded I guess, but not much about the actual situation.

I think this is still not such a great look for Rust. I had expected interfacing Rust to C to present fewer problems than it seems to. I had hoped the Rust compiler could produce object code with almost no runtime dependencies, the way C compilers can. So integrating Rust code into the kernel should be fairly painless from the C side, if things were as one would hope.

It does sound to me in the earlier post that there was some toxicity going on. Maybe it had something to do with the context being a DRM driver.

I looked at a few Rust tutorials but they seemed to take forever to get to any interesting parts. I will keep looking.

in reply to solrize

Skull giver
lemmy - Link to source
Skull giver
• •
This entry was edited (4 months ago)
in reply to Skull giver

tabular
lemmy - Link to source
tabular
• •
"DRM" as in digital restrictions management I assume.
in reply to tabular

merthyr1831
lemmy - Link to source
merthyr1831
• •
DRM in this context (as mentioned by the other comment) is the interface between the userspace graphics drivers (Mesa, Nouveau, Nvidia etc.) and your graphics devices. It handles pretty much everything for rendering from displays to power management and memory synchronization, in a cooperative way that stops crashes due to race conditions, memory corruption etc.
in reply to Skull giver

merthyr1831
lemmy - Link to source
merthyr1831
• •

Your point about it being a culture issue is spot on. Many maintainers who are established in the kernel have made it clear they'd rather keep the status quo and the comfort of stagnation rather than bring a new technology forward to improve the security of their systems.

If it wasn't Rust, but some other language with similar benefits, the same people would've thrown their hands in the air and complained that they're being forced to rewrite everything or some other hyperbole.

Because it's a FOSS project, for some reason it's acceptable for maintainers to be entitled arseholes who abuse anyone they personally have a vendetta against.

In any other workplace, this behaviour wouldn't be called "nontechnical concerns" it would be called workplace bullying. And as much as Linus wants to say he's working on his anger issues, he is personally one of the contributors who has set this culture of aggression and politicking as much as any other.

in reply to Skull giver

merthyr1831
lemmy - Link to source
merthyr1831
• •
As an aside, the DRM and its support for the supposedly superior-on-linux AMD-powered devices is atrocious. I've had my laptop since January and it's a model from 2023, but it still regularly has mega display corruption from memory mismanagement that might be improved from a certain language feature not offered in C.
⇧