Skip to main content


There's a *ton* of interesting stuff in this pod with Alon Levy about why US public transit is so f'ing expensive, but I really want to highlight what I take as his Main Point, to wit ...

US transit costs and how to ta...

reshared this

in reply to David Roberts

... the countries that build public transit well, quickly, & cheaply all have something in common: most of the work is done by the government itself, using in-house expertise, rather than farming various parts out to private companies under the bullshit theory that private always = more efficient.
in reply to David Roberts

In other words, a robust, respected, well-paid, well-staffed bureaucracy is the key to accomplishing large-scale public works project on time and under budget. Cutting public agencies to the bone & farming out their responsibilities to the private sector *doesn't work*.
in reply to David Roberts

Those Scandinavian countries we all admire? Here's their secret: their private sector is private, their public sector is public. Their markets tend to be more free & less regulated than US markets. Conversely, their public works projects are *public*, planned & executed by public agencies.
in reply to David Roberts

In the US, almost everything is a shitty, inefficient mix of the two. The private sector is overregulated & the tax code is a f'ing nightmare of complexity. On the other side, the public sector is unerstaffed & underfunded, forced to farm out key work to parasitic private consultants.
in reply to David Roberts

The result is shitty performance on both sides: a corrupt & rent-seeking private sector that's not growing as fast as it could, and an ineffective, hapless public sector that systematically underperforms & drains public trust. It sucks. It benefits no one but the oligarchs.