Skip to main content


1/ I'm doing what I can to track the actions and positions of the new #Trump admin on open and uncensored research. But it's far more than a one-person job. This is a post on what I'm doing โ€” building up to a call to help find ways to #crowdsource the work.

#Censorship #DefendResearch #OAintheUSA, #OpenAccess #OpenScience #ScholComm #Takedowns #Universities

๐Ÿงต

in reply to petersuber

in reply to petersuber

3/ The Mastodon work is essentially solo. There are no "guest posts" on Mastodon accounts, tho I do boost the posts of others.

By contrast, the OATP work is collaborative and #crowdsourced. Most of the items that we capture on these topics we tag with "oa.trump47". Here's what we've tagged so far:
tagteam.harvard.edu/hubs/oatp/โ€ฆ

If you want to tag for OATP and help this cause, here's how to get started or see what's involved.
bit.ly/oatp-start-tagging

This entry was edited (8 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

4/ But #OATP can't be the only #crowdsourced component of this project.

First, many people who'd like to contribute would rather post to #SocialMedia or contribute to #Wikipedia than tag for a tagging project.

Second, the scope of OATP has is narrower than many contributors would like.

Third, OATP itself has an uncertain future.
bit.ly/TransferOATP

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

5/ I collect and reformat many of my project-related Mastodon posts on a #wiki page, for those who don't want to visit Mastodon. (The same wiki page collects my Twitter posts on the first Trump admin.)
bit.ly/TrumpOA

But this isn't crowdsourced either. Unlike most other wikis, this one isn't open for public edits and can't be. I launched it at the @bkc it to hold the deliverables for some of my grant-funded #OpenAccess projects.

This entry was edited (5 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

6/ I'm writing this thread this to brainstorm with all of you on other ways to #crowdsource this work.
This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

7/ For example, I see many #SocialMedia posts on these topics but not much convergence in the #hashtags they use. #Trump, #USPol, and #USPolitics are common but they're not specific to these topics. We need to supplement them with tags that are more specific.

#DefendResearch is new with the Feb 13 Declaration to Defend Research. (Disclosure: I'm a co-author.)
defendresearch.org/

The tag is catching on but not yet widespread. Can we help it spread?

This entry was edited (5 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

8/ Are there other tags we should foster for this purpose? Ideally they should be specific to these topics, short, and self-explanatory.

To help people monitor what's happening, we should try to get reasonably wide agreement on the best tags to use.

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

9/ I love #Wikipedia as a reader and served on the @wikimediafoundation Advisory Board for a few years. But my experience as a contributor has been largely negative.

Could we do this monitoring job on Wikipedia without inviting editors to take it down for violating the neutral point of view (#NPOV)?

We should be able to. The actions of the Trump admin, and the actions of those pushing back, are public and could be logged neutrally. But I'm not optimistic that such a list would survive for long. Could any #Wikipedians advise or help with that?

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

10/ #Trump is doing damage on many fronts, not just the front of open and uncensored research. Are there projects to #crowdsource info on all of that damage? If so, the project on damage to research could be part of that larger project.

I welcome your thoughts.

#OAintheUSA #OpenAccess #OpenScience

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to petersuber

I've had a similar impulse today though for German readership. For English, there seem to be quite a few resources, like Keep Track and others in the replies to my post: ohai.social/@sonjdol/114029432โ€ฆ

As for hashtags, I use Trump, Uspol, and Musk, sometimes democracy, but these could be more specific.

in reply to sonja dolinsek

Thx. These are good and I didn't know about them. I just joined the r/Keep_Track subreddit.

I also used @birb to create an RSS feed of the Keep Track Substack account that users can follow it on #Mastodon.
@keeptrack.substack.com.p.project-2025-tracker-is-now-live

in reply to petersuber

I've had this going from day 2 of the administration โ€” 47-watch.com/index.html and will ensure I link to the tagteam tracker
in reply to petersuber

applaud your efforts, and would welcome the opportunity to financially support anything concrete. please continue to post and share.
in reply to petersuber

11/ A recently added piece of my tracking project is this Google doc of public statements supporting research and higher education against threats from the Trump administration.
docs.google.com/document/d/1Y5โ€ฆ

It includes a list of other projects tracking Trump admin actions the same topics.

Please suggest any statements or projects that belong in the doc.
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIโ€ฆ

#Academia #Censorship #DefendResearch #Takedowns #Trump #TrumpVResearch #USPol #USPolitics
@academicchatter

Tim Chambers reshared this.

in reply to petersuber

Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source
petersuber

I like the idea of an "Effects on Science" Wikipedia page, provided we had some confidence the page wouldn't be taken down for violating NPOV. (I have a lot of experience that makes me pessimistic.) I'm hoping that some Wikipedians will weigh in on that, either to tell us not to bother or to suggest ways to reduce the risk.

Related: #JustSecurity is tracking lawsuits against the Trump admin.
justsecurity.org/107087/trackeโ€ฆ

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source
petersuber
@JMMaok @wikimediafoundation
Might be worth a try. But not all the bad effects on science (that I want to track) are effects of EOs. Some are effects of ad hoc administrative decisions, Musk ransacking, and so on. If we could use Wikipedia to log the damage to research, I'd want to log damage beyond the EOs.
in reply to petersuber

Are you aware of the work around #SafeguardingResearch ? The only person that I can recall now is @jonny but I will add the others once I remember.
โ‡ง