Skip to main content


It's not just you. US healthcare, already a bureaucratic nightmare of buck-passing and price-gouging, has gotten *far* worse. Private equity firms have created regional health-care monopolies that don't just rip patients off - they're *killing* us.

Private equity is a scam. Fund managers raise gigantic sums by claiming to be able to "beat the market." In reality, they do worse for their investors than a boring old index fund:

pluralistic.net/2020/02/25/plu…

1/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

The fund managers don't have to beat the market in order to make bank. They can take advantage of the "carried interest" loophole, which has nothing to do with interest rates - it's a tax system that was invented for 16th century sea-captains (no, really):

pluralistic.net/2021/04/29/wri…

2/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

PE dresses up its playbook in all kinds of bullshit, but it's a smokescreen. At core, PE funds buy companies, merge them to monopoly, slash wages, fire staff, load up their businesses with debt, and then skedaddle before the businesses collapse. They call this "creating value":

pluralistic.net/2020/07/24/sof…

3/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

This playbook guarantees that everything PE touches will turn to shit. PE is a parasite that preys on weak industries and makes them even more dysfunctional. Think of how PE has cornered regional rental housing markets and then turned every rental in town into a slum:

pluralistic.net/2022/02/08/wal…

4/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Most of us didn't really think about rail-freight until last winter, when the whole system nearly collapsed. Again, the bloody handprints of PE are all over that crisis:

pluralistic.net/2022/02/04/up-…

The pandemic put a lot of businesses into a precarious state, and PE swooped in, buying up distressed businesses at scale and putting them into a death-spiral:

pluralistic.net/2020/03/30/med…

5/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

This acquisition was fueled by Trump's corporate covid bailout and the trillions in public money that the GOP made available to corporate borrowers (remember, PE thrives on debt):

pluralistic.net/2020/09/17/div…

Of all the sick industries in America, healthcare is the sickest, and it's the domain where PE has done the most damage. PE stripped healthcare systems to the bone, removing all excess capacity and exhausting and demoralizing healthcare workers:

pluralistic.net/2020/05/21/pro…

6/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

They bought up emergency rooms, turned them into scam factories that hit every unfortunate person who stepped foot in them with thousands in "surprise billing" fees. Then they cut doctors' pay and spent millions on ads to block anti-surprise billing legislation:

pluralistic.net/2020/04/21/all…

7/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

The ER scam was and is wild. Some hospitals lock all their doors except for the ER doors, and then they'd hit you for "emergency care" when you went through the ER on your way to receiving normal, non-emergency procedures:

pluralistic.net/2022/03/14/unh…

The damage wasn't limited to emergency rooms. Whole hospitals - whole hospital *systems* - were crashed by PE looters, and many of these got emergency government bailouts, because...free market?

pluralistic.net/2020/10/01/the…

8/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

PE has bought its way into every corner of the health-care system, and made every bad thing, much, much worse. You know how "bad nursing home" are three of the scariest words in the English language? Try on "bad private equity owned nursing home" for size. The death toll is *massive*:

pluralistic.net/2021/02/23/acc…

9/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Biden's SEC chair Gary Gensler has made the most decisive anti-PE moves in decades, requiring disclosures that will help investors (especially union pension funds) pierce the veil of bullshit that brings in the billions that PE fashions into weapons of financial mass destruction:

pluralistic.net/2022/02/10/mon…

But the wheels of justice grind slow, and PE has trillions to fuel its race to suck every bit of value out of the health-care system before the party comes to an end.

10/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

In "Sick Profit: Investigating Private Equity’s Stealthy Takeover of Health Care Across Cities and Specialties," *Kaiser Health News*'s Fred Schulte reveals the plan of attack:

khn.org/news/article/private-e…

In 2021, PE firms bought 1,400 health care companies, spending $206b (the total since 2012 is more than $1t). They've cornered regional markets for eye care, dental care, family practices, hospices, and pet care. We've had a year to see how that played out, and it's not pretty.

11/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Since 2014, PE have paid out $500m in fines for falsifying billings to the US government, but a fine is a price, and the fines have been absorbed into PE's business plans as part of the cost of operations.

Once a PE firm buys up all the specialists in a region, things get very bad. Take San Antonio, where nearly all the gastroenterology clinics have been bought up by PE firms, and where routine colonoscopies now cost patients thousands more than they paid before:

khn.org/news/article/private-e…

12/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

While there are plenty of illegal ways that PE companies extract value from their acquisitions, the legal tactics are pretty ugly all on their own, like cutting staff and replacing them with less skilled, less trained, cheaper workers, putting patients at risk.

13/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

This is particularly worrying when you consider how heavily PE companies invest in practices to treat people who are vulnerable and struggle to advocate for themselves, such as behavioral health specialists who treat autism, addiction and mental illness.

Whether or not you can escape PE depends a lot on where you live. PE only owns 12% of the nation's anesthesiology practices, but those practices are concentrated in five states, where more than two thirds of anesthesiologists are PE owned.

14/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

When PE takes over your care, billings go way up. The average PE-treated patient generates $71 more per claim, and is 9% more likely to experience "lengthy, more costly" care:

jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-…

Doctors who sell their practices to PE companies are lured in with promises of administrative relief from experts who'll handle billing, scheduling and compliance. But PE firms exercise fine-grained control over these doctors, violating rules that say medical practices must be run by MDs.

15/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Take National Spine, a PE-backed chain owned by Sentinel Capital Partners that bought up 40+ pain-management clinics across the country. Doctors saw their caseload explode from 16 patients/day to 25. Medicare billings also exploded, with "unnecessary and often worthless" back braces being charged at up to $1,100 each. Patients were given $1,800 "medically unnecessary and often worthless" urine tests. National settled these claims for $3.3m in April 2019, without admitting guilt.

16/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

RLH Equity Partners's pharmacies bilked the military health insurer Tricare out of $68m through a system of kickbacks and telemarketer sales. RLH settled the case for $21m and blamed it on a few corrupt "individuals."

Most of the time, fraud claims are settled by the companies that the PE funds owe, while the PE funds themselves get off scot-free. That leaves the funds free to re-offend, and to further push the limits on patient endangerment.

17/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

One of the grisliest parts of this tale is in the realm of children's dentistry. PE firms have bought up these practices and turned them into high-volume Medicare-fraud assembly lines that perform rushed, unnecessary major procedures on poor kids and bill the government a fortune for them.

18/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Child death

These include baby root canals and crowns, and the PE-backed dental chains set quotas for their staff, requiring them to perform a certain number of major procedures on each patient. One particularly horrifying case recounted by the KHN article is that of two-year old Zion Gastelum, who died following major dental surgery.

19/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Child death

Gastelum received six root canals and crowns on his baby teeth at a PE-owned Kool Smiles clinic in Yuma, AZ. The oxygen bottle used during his surgery "was empty or not operating properly" and the staff who oversaw the procedure were undertrained and didn't notice. He never regained consciousness, and died of brain injuries days later.

20/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Child death

Kool Smiles's owners paid $24m to settle a DoJ overbilling claim less than a month later. The settlement alleged that Kool Smiles performed unnecessary procedures, including baby root canals. Kool Smiles denied that they were responsible for Gastelum's death.

21/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

More than 90% of PE acquisitions fall below the $101m threshold for antitrust review, so they fly under the radar. Once the mergers are complete, they are very hard to unwind. The FTC is working its way through hundreds of comments from doctors or other health care workers asking for tighter scrutiny of health-care mergers.

22/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

The Healthcare Private Equity Association boasts that its members are poised to spend more than $3t to create "the future of healthcare."

hcpea.org/#!event-list

--

Image:
Rae Allen (modified)
flickr.com/photos/raeallen/622…

CC BY 2.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b…

Videoplasty (modified)
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fil…

CC BY-SA 4.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b…

eof/

in reply to Cory Doctorow

These constant “killer acquisitions” by large players need way more scrutiny. We tried… gov.uk/government/publications…
in reply to Cory Doctorow

My parents took me to a civilian dentist with our military insurance. Next thing I knew, I had fillings in all of my molars. Didn't go to a dentist for over ten years after that.
in reply to Cory Doctorow

Hmm. There's gotta be a way to have Mastodon just show page one on the timeline. Looking into that.
in reply to mharr

I believe you can set the first post to a global audience and make the rest unlisted. Anyone can see unlisted posts as comments (or if linked directly), but they don't display in the timeline.
in reply to Stuart Broz

you have misunderstood how hidden posts work. Posts are only hidden for non followers on the same instance. If you don't like my posting style, my bio explains how to get my essays elsewhere and you can unfollow me here.
in reply to Cory Doctorow

Ah, right. If unlisted, followers will still see them in their home stream, they just won't show up in the local and federated timelines, I think? Still trying to get the hang of precisely how everything works (like a million other people).

I can deal with the format myself. I'm just glad you're here.

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Aye, I'm finding the general problem with learning to toot is that everything operates just a few degrees starboard of the way I'd expect and that seems to apply to server admins as well as users.

Just don't follow can't be the only solution on a federated open source platform though - the problem isn't Cory's posting style, it's a lack of timeline management tools for users. He's putting page numbers on everything, filtering this should be *easy*.

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Well, I found a stupid brute force option that works for now: Set individual filters for 2/ 3/ 4/ etc.

Quite amused that searching for generalized solutions to this immediately brings up your name in various forums :P

in reply to Cory Doctorow

I think of rail freight when I'm on a passenger train, delayed for hours by freight trains, in violation of the law guaranteeing priority to passenger trains
in reply to Cory Doctorow

Heartbreaking and sickening. Is there anything these monsters won't do to steal the future from the rest of us? #USHealthcare #Capitalism
in reply to Cory Doctorow

Cory I wish you moved from Mastodon to Friendica and make long nice posts rather than so many little ones :) - you are always welcomed to our instance at social.trom.tf . For me it is so difficult to read the so many posts. I know I can go on your website, and I do, but just saying, could be far better for all on the fediverse. Inline media, stylize text, long posts, add to categories, etc..

Mark reshared this.

in reply to Tio

please see my bio for ways to read my daily essays off mastodon if you don't like my posting style here
in reply to Cory Doctorow

Yes thanks Cory, I know.

But I was suggesting an alternative that could be a lot better for the fediverse overall.
in reply to Tio

I use this instance because it is run by a well regarded digital human rights group with a history of resisting surveillance and censorship demands. That is far more important than character limits to me.
in reply to Cory Doctorow

I understand. Fair enough. I would say our project and our instance is "resisting surveillance and censorship demands" as well, quite to the extreme perhaps because I want for people to have a voice and I would not easily accept the removal of accounts if asked by 3rd parties.
in reply to Cory Doctorow

One of the first orders of homeschooling business was to teach the kids to save and invest [we incentivized by matching what they set aside as savings from allowance] - and that investment is always - as kids have advised some adults even - in a passively managed total stock market index fund.

(this is essentially what Warren Buffet challenged fund managers to beat and still stands)

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Hey, you should update your syndication feed so you're posting this on mastodon-sized chunks instead of twitter-sized ones, at least